Does WordPress meet your needs yet?
Monday
Jul 28, 2008
The inexorable drive toward improvement (dare I say perfection?) that characterises the WordPress project is not only a source of benefit, but also one of the main causes of difficulty and complaint. When WordPress 2.5 was released people complained about the new interface. At every release people complain that there are too many upgrades. Surely WordPress is good enough already?
It seems to me that WordPress is heading in a direction. I am not confident in the destination, intended or otherwise, but each new feature adds complexity and takes WordPress further from the ‘dead simple, gets things done’ WordPress that initially attracted me.
My first attraction to WordPress was a direct reaction against enterprise content management systems that are rediculously over specified and restrictive, and their open source cousin Joomla, so naturally I want to WordPress to keep its place as their oposite.
To an extent, that means reigning back the new features and considering how the system operates. What I would really like to see is the modularisation of the core. I would like WordPress to be a shell featuring user management, URL management, and a blank admin panel, into which each feature inserts itself in the same way as plugins add themselves.
This means that every feature (or combined features where absolutely necessary) sits in its own folder and can be deactivated, replaced or even deleted without any ramifications except the loss of that feature.
I think Backpress will help with this, but I don’t think it will ever happen. The attraction of adding new features is a strong one and far more interesting than altering parts of the code that most people never touch, or even see.
WordPress already meets my needs as a user. There is nothing more I need or want. Security patches aside is there really any need to add anything else?







Comments
Jé Maverick (http://www.jemaverick.com/)
July 29th, 2008 at 7:19 am
I do think that it is fast approaching the point of becoming bloatware. If there are no security risks in a version, I prefer sticking to that until it becomes really necessary to upgrade. The architecture and the function of a Wordpress blog remains pretty much the same…why bother with the continuous roll-outs when an ultra stable and thoroughly tested version would suffice?
Stefano, wordpressmania.it (http://www.wordpressmania.it)
July 30th, 2008 at 9:31 am
I agree, and @Jé: the point is tha aven for security upgrades they put new features in the box, or change some admin panel etc… so you have to upgrade for the security concern but you ends in haveng an “empowered” Wp even if you don’t need it
Stefano
Jacob Santos
August 1st, 2008 at 5:19 pm
BackPress is not meant to be the modularization of WordPress, but a single point of the core library for all of the Presses.
I would also like to see modularization of WordPress and plan on writing some code to allow for it.
Jacob Santos
August 3rd, 2008 at 11:57 pm
You can check http://trac.wordpress.org/ticket/5625 again for basic support for the uninstall hook.
Andrew Rickmann (http://www.arickmann.co.uk)
August 4th, 2008 at 7:40 am
Thanks Jacob.